Documentary Review: ‘An Eye For An Eye’

by | Aug 11, 2026 | Movie Reviews, Movies | 0 comments


Greetings again from the darkness. This can’t be right. It doesn’t seem real. Yet, it’s possibly the harshest form of reality. Documentarians Tanaz Ashaghian and Farzad Jafari managed to gain access to two families during a process most of us westerners can’t fathom. I had to keep reminding myself this is a documentary and these are real people from real families. Theirs is a true story … a legal and cultural and family thriller with real consequences.

In Tehran, a man discovers a corpse buried in the floor of his kitchen. The previous tenants included Taherah, who was then arrested, convicted of murder, and sent to prison for fourteen years. Her defense for killing her husband was his drug abuse led to his violence towards her … as evidenced by hospital visits for treatment of injuries incurred. She had requested a divorce, but in Iran, divorce is typically only granted when instigated by the husband. So, Taherah, along with her daughters, did what they felt was needed to protect themselves. The other two were pardoned, and Taherah served her 14 year prison sentence.

Now you may think that story is tragic … and you’d be correct. However, it’s just the beginning here. Saria Law in Iran states the family of the murder victim decides between execution and forgiveness (accompanied with diya, or blood money). This is AFTER the prison sentence is served. In this case, the decision falls to Taherah’s in-laws, specifically Bashir, her brother-in-law. Her fate is in his hands. The elderly mother-in-law demands execution, but again, this is Iran, so it falls to the man.

The Quran promotes “an eye for an eye”, while also claiming forgiveness is better. An anti-execution advocacy group is brought in to assist with the negotiations, and a hefty sum is settled upon. It’s a shocking amount of money for the poor family and if they can’t raise it, execution is the only step. In another twist of fate, Bashir’s eldest son must assume the negotiations, and he takes a hardline approach despite the efforts of the advocacy group and the pleas from Taherah’s son, Mohsen.

It’s remarkable just how much of this process the filmmakers capture for us to witness. We are often inside private homes or in closed door negotiations … truly eavesdropping on life and death matters. The stress and tension will be felt by each viewer as negotiations and the courtroom drama play out. Ashaghian and Farzad have delivered a terrific documentary that will certainly take most viewers out of their comfort zone and open eyes to a world we struggle to comprehend.

Opens in theaters on August 12, 2026 and will be available digitally on Jolt.film beginning August 14, 2026

David Ferguson
Latest posts by David Ferguson (see all)