Tweet
Review by James Lindorf
The “Hunger Games” franchise has had its ups and downs. 2013’s “Catching Fire” remains the high point, and the three films that followed have struggled to reach it. The two-part “Mockingjay” story felt unnecessarily drawn out, and “The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes” was an enjoyable enough trip back to Panem, but it didn’t make me eager to revisit the originals. The latest entry, “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping,” managed to do just that. According to Lionsgate, this will be the final entry unless a new book is written, and going out with the best film since “Catching Fire” is a great way to bring things to a close. It works because of the script, and it falls short of “Catching Fire” for the same reason: the script tells us how much the characters love each other instead of showing us why we should care. “Sunrise on the Reaping” opens everywhere on November 20th.
I am generally skeptical of prequels. Too often they feel like an excuse to explain things that never needed explaining, and sometimes a little mystery is better. This one offers some worthwhile insight into Haymitch Abernathy, including small character details that take on a different meaning when you think about the man we meet in the original films. The story follows sixteen-year-old Haymitch (Joseph Zada) from District 12, beginning on the morning of the reaping for the 50th Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, with twice as many tributes as usual. Whitney Peak plays Haymitch’s girlfriend Lenore Dove, with Mckenna Grace (Maysilee), Molly McCann (Louella), and Ben Wang (Wyatt) as the fellow District 12 tributes, led by Glenn Close as chief escort Drusilla. New faces in old roles include Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, Elle Fanning as a young Effie Trinket, and Kelvin Harrison Jr. as Beetee Latier.
The film leans hardest on what it can’t fully prove: that this teenager grows into Woody Harrelson’s Haymitch. Zada, GQ Australia’s “Breakout Actor of the Year,” does a good job handling the action and drama, and he is not afraid to cry. There are multiple shots of him from above with tears collecting on the tip of his nose, and someone really liked that image because it happens at least three times. I didn’t think his impression of Harrelson added to or detracted from the film, despite some of the praise surrounding it. It is also a little strange that he seems to be the only person around him who talks or acts like Harrelson’s Haymitch. Not even his family shares those mannerisms.
The Capitol is where the movie shows instead of tells. Fiennes is probably the best Snow we’ve seen: a physical threat (even though that isn’t what Snow is about) and a complete psychopath willing to harm himself as cover for his need to manipulate the populace while ruling with an iron fist. How he survived to be so old in the original series is a mystery. Close is great because you hate her guts and want bad things to happen to her. Think Dolores Umbridge. Drusilla is everything Effie is, but more evil. Culkin is a less flamboyant but more brutal Caesar who really drives home the pyrrhic nature of Haymitch’s win. And Plemons captivates you whenever he’s on screen. For much of the film, it is hard to tell whether his character is good, evil, or somewhere in between, and that unpredictability makes him feel more dangerous than many of the franchise’s other antagonists. Fanning plays a sweeter, less jaded Effie who still cares about looks and manners, and if she weren’t here, the prequel wouldn’t miss her.
Louella proves what the rest of the film could have done. Molly McCann plays her as a sweet, charming, innocent girl trying to navigate a world where children fight to the death for entertainment, and her discomfort with the gambling around the Games gives the film a welcome perspective on the system’s cruelty. She is also the instigating factor in Haymitch’s clash with Snow, and we feel why she matters without anyone declaring it. She is my favorite new character, and I wish the film had given her more to do. Grace is fine as the tough, snarky Maysilee, determined to die with dignity if she can’t win. They tease an angsty teen hate-to-love romance that might have developed if Haymitch weren’t devoted to Lenore Dove and they weren’t fighting to the death.
Lenore Dove is where the film does the opposite. Peak is terrific and draws your attention whenever she is on screen. Still, her character spends most of the film causing Haymitch to end up in the Games and declaring her love for him. We are told repeatedly how much these two mean to each other, including a melodramatic, frequently repeated line, “I love you like all-fire.” I never felt it as strongly as the movie wanted me to. I wanted more moments that showed why they matter to each other and fewer where they state it. It also leaves Haymitch a bit disconnected from his future self. He promises her he will break the machine that is the Games, to prevent another reaping. Yet, that anger and determination seem untouched for the next 25 years. The younger Haymitch is too openly defiant for the man we eventually meet, leaving us to fill in the blanks.
The same gap shows up in the Games themselves. Making the 50th Games the largest ever, with 48 tributes, feels like a missed opportunity. Doubling the competitors should mean more dangerous Games and more interesting alliances and rivalries. Instead, many disappear in a couple of major moments, and the focus quickly returns to Haymitch, with cross-district scheming already underway before most of them make an impression. I understand wanting to stay centered on Haymitch, but then why make such a significant change if you aren’t going to do anything with it? There is also more posturing than fighting. Thankfully, what is there is choreographed fairly well, but when you only need 30 seconds, messing it up should be difficult. The animal attacks are the most memorable action, especially the pink birds and the taser butterflies. The costumes and sets bring this version of Panem to life, while the CGI creatures struggle with photorealism when they are simply moving through the environment. Oddly, they work better when they are attacking, because the motion and blurring hide the seams. The score is serviceable. Francis Lawrence’s direction is solid and remains the connective tissue for the series.
My biggest issue is that it runs too long, and I don’t think the answer is to cut 20 minutes. It is more about pacing and how the time is used. The repeated declarations of love, the extended emotional torment, and a drawn-out ending with multiple funerals make it feel more melodramatic than moving. A couple of cameos from familiar characters also feel unnecessary. Woody’s appearance makes sense given the story, but the film didn’t need to bring in everyone else to take away from his emotional journey.
“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” is for fans of the series. However, a newcomer could follow it without much explanation. It is the 50th Games, so knowing the full history is impossible anyway. It does a sufficient job of showing how Haymitch became the broken man of the first film, and it made me want to go back and watch the originals, which the last prequel never accomplished. I wish it had spent less time telling us how much its characters love one another and more time showing us why. That is what makes this a good addition to the franchise and not a great one, earning it a 3.5 out of 5.
Rating: PG-13 (Disturbing Material|Bloody Images|Some Smoking|Strong Violence|Teen Drinking)
Genre: Action, Adventure
Original Language: English
Release Date (Theaters): November 20th, 2026, Wide
Runtime: 2h 38m
Director: Francis Lawrence
Producer: Nina Jacobson, Brad Simpson, Francis Lawrence
Screenwriter: Billy Ray, Michael Lesslie
Distributor: Lionsgate
Production Co: Color Force
- Movie Review: ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping’ - November 20, 2026
- Watch Trailer For ‘Ice Age: Boiling Point’ In Theaters Feb. 5th - November 19, 2026
- Minneapolis: Win Passes To An Advance Screening Of ‘Focker In-Law’ - November 18, 2026
