Documentary Review: ‘You Had To Be There’

by | Nov 19, 2026 | Movie Reviews, Movies | 0 comments


Greetings again from the darkness. Were one to return to the year 1972, notable events would include the Watergate break-in, the release of THE GODFATHER, Boris Spassky facing off against Bobby Fischer in Iceland, the Dow closing above 1000 for the first time, and Mark Spitz winning seven Olympic gold medals in swimming … the same year of the shooting in the Munich Olympic village. As with most years, there was tragedy and triumph and history-making. Director Nick Davis and producer Judd Apatow bring us memories of one of the more joyous events that year: the stage production of “Godspell” at the Royal Alexandra Theater in Toronto.

The title of this film gives away the reason the 1972 “Godspell” is not only remembered today, but also so influential to the popularity of comedy in the 1970’s and beyond. Cast members included Gilda Radner, Martin Short, Eugene Levy, Andrea Martin, Dave Thomas, and Victor Garber … names you recognize from “Saturday Night Live”, “Second City”, and numerous other TV series and movies. Equally amazing is that twenty-two-year-old Paul Shaffer (later known for “Late Night with David Letterman”) was named Musical Director of the production. Today, that lineup is a ‘Who’s Who’, yet at the time, these were complete unknowns.

It’s a bit frustrating that no video exists from the live performances of this cast, but thanks to Martin Short, an audio recording has been saved and a portion is played here. The late John-Michael Tebelak wrote the play and based it on the gospel of Saint Matthew. Stephen Schwartz composed the music (including the popular hit song “Day by Day”), and in his interview he raves about the cast and talent of Tebelak. All of the surviving cast members participate in the film, including Avril Chown and Patty Eastwood.

A reunion provides the highlight of the film, and it’s clear that these folks remain close after more than fifty years. They honor the past and each other’s talents. A video clip of a rehearsal is played and all eyes are fixed on the screen. Almost immediately, tears roll from those eyes. Another favorite segment of the film involves recollections of the audition process … especially Gilda Radner’s pigtails and her lively spirit. “Schoolhouse Rock” style animation is used in place of archival footage, and we learn that the house Martin Short and Eugene Levy shared became the party house for the cast. Cast members were paid $160 per week during the production, and Victor Garber went on to play Jesus in the film version (the only Canadian). This Nick Davis’ documentary serves as a tribute to Canada and the performers.

Coming to VOD on November 20, 2026

David Ferguson